| Dr. Ebenezer Johnson | 1832 and 1834 |
| Major A.Andrews | 1833 |
| Hiram Pratt | 1835 and 1839 |
| Samuel Wilkeson | 1836 |
| Dr. Josiah Trowbridge | 1837 |
| Pierre A. Barker | 1837 |
| Ebenezer Walden | 1838 |
| Capt. Sheldon Thompson | 1840 |
| Issac R. Harrington | 1841 |
| George W. Clinton | 1842 |
| Joseph G. Masten | 1843 and 1845 |
| William Ketchum | 1844 |
| Solomon G.Haven | 1846 |
| Elbridge G. Spaulding | 1847 |
| Orlando Allen | 1848 |
| Hiram Barton | 1849 and 1852 |
| Henry K. Smith | 1850 |
| James Wadsworth | 1851 |
| Eli Cook | 1853-1855 |
| Frederick P. Stevens | 1856-1857 |
| Timothy T. Lockwood | 1858-1859 |
| Franklin A. Alberger | 1860-1861 |
| William G. Fargo | 1862-1865 |
| Chandler J. Wells | 1866-1867 |
| Maj. Gen. William F. Rogers | 1868-1869 |
| Alexander Brush | 1870-1873 and 1880-1881 |
| Louis P. Dayton | 1874-1875 |
| Philip Becker | 1876-1877 and 1886-1889 |
| Solomon Scheu | 1878-1879 |
| Grover Cleveland | 1882 |
| Marcus M. Drake | 1882 |
| Harmon S. Cutting | 1882 |
| John B. Manning | 1883 |
| Jonathan Scoville | 1884-1885 |
| Charles F. Bishop | 1890-1894 |
| Edgar B. Jewett | 1895-1897 |
| Conrad Diehl | 1898-1901 |
| Erastus C. Knight | 1902-1905 |
| James N. Adam | 1906-1909 |
| Louis P. Fuhrmann | 1910-1917 |
| George S. Buck | 1918-1921 |
| Frank X. Schwab | 1922-1929 |
| Charles E. Roesch | 1930-1933 |
| George J. Zimmerman | 1934-1937 |
| Thomas L. Holling | 1938-1941 |
| Joseph J. Kelly | 1942-1945 |
| Bernard J. Dowd | 1946-1949 |
| Joseph Mruk | 1950-1953 |
| Steven Pan kow | 1954-1957 |
| Frank A. Sedita | 1958-1961 and 1966-1973 |
| Chester Kowal | 1962-1965 |
| Stanley M. Makowski | 1973-1977 |
| James D. Griffin | 1978-1994 |
| Anthony Masiello | 1994-Present |